What are your thoughts?

[xIIRevoEvoS]

Since I won't be making a trip to Kingsford to acquire a 50L bag of Pumice due to the long trip.
What are everyones thought about Diatomite 2-7mm, Scoria 2-3mm, Zeolite and Perlite 2-5mm?

From what I've read is that Perlite and Pumice has the same properties which is aerating soil, 1 is light than the other, both are white vs the other is slightly darker.
If Perlite isn't an ideal additive to the mix for aeration, what other alternative can I get for Pumice or without Perlite is fine?

What about Fine gravel / grit opposed to Perlite?

I know this has been discussed in Soil Supply Post, but I would like advice on current sources/mixture.

[peterb]

Hi revo
perlite isn't the same as pumice , pumice holds a large amount of moisture trapped inside . You can plant your tree in pure pumice and many do, i for one . Diatomite is also a very good inorganic soil and can also be used by itself and i do that to . I tend to add a little say 20-30 % of orchid pine bark in the +- 5mm range. I've never tried scoria as i've not found it in the size i want and never used zeolite or perlite but from what i understand perlite doesn't hold a lot of moisture.
regards
peterb

[Boics]

Perlite can also be very messy as it is very light and dry Perlite on a pots surface can blow away in the wind.

[Isitangus]

Perlite holds very little to no moisture, but for me the lightness is a good thing, especially in larger pots.
It's primary purpose is to aid in aeration.
I would say in your mix there wouldn't be much need for it-all of your components would be pretty free draining anyway. Except scoria + zeolite = heavier so may consider swapping scoria for perlite.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[xIIRevoEvoS]

Perlite holds very little to no moisture, but for me the lightness is a good thing, especially in larger pots.
It's primary purpose is to aid in aeration.
I would say in your mix there wouldn't be much need for it-all of your components would be pretty free draining anyway. Except scoria + zeolite = heavier so may consider swapping scoria for perlite.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I've also seen propagators use purely Perlite to grow various plants which also intrigues me.
Been told to add a minimum of 10% of scoria with the current grade of 2-3mm and Zeolite is probably 5%, no more.
Perlite won't be added on top of the bonsai pot.
I bought 1 Medium Ausperl Perlite from Pet&Garden as well as Diatomite.
Zeolte from Nesci as well. Need to get Pumice when I feel like travelling to Kingsford and not as far as Caringbah Bonsai South.