AusBonsai

Hi Grant,

With or without Jin..I like it both. It all depends on what the story is you'd like to tell about the tree.

Good luck with you recovery.

it's specky 4 sure very nice work

I love the tree and love the pot.
The jin is good in the original pot but clashes with the apex of the new pot.
Are we talking about this pot or one similar?
If you use a pot with a little less height you could keep the jin. JMHO

Gerard

i reckon gerard might be onto something there, if the pot could be made with less height you will be on a winner if that is the only reason for the jin removal, removing or shortening that jin takes a bit away from the trees story i reckon, i reckon it is needed!

tough decision grant!


jamie

There aren't any of these pots in Canberra so I will have a look next time I am down in Melbourne. Its always difficult till you see, feel the pot and really get a handle on it.

Thanks for the feed back.

Grant

Grant Bowie wrote:There aren't any of these pots in Canberra so I will have a look next time I am down in Melbourne. Its always difficult till you see, feel the pot and really get a handle on it.

Thanks for the feed back.

Grant

Lorraine Simpson of the Morington Penisula bonsai Club mate she will custom make it if you give her the measurements. I will pm her email

Hi Grant,

I really like the look of your cedar in the proposed pot but... that jin... Just kidding!

Excellent virt too Psymo!

Regards,
Steven

The present pot would seem to be a tad too dark and massive.

The jin is wild - a must-keep feature. The top of the new pot clashes with it, so not a good match.

Maybe a grey unglazed pot with a smaller base or a bit less visual mass?

Let the tree do the talking.

Just a thought. I'd love to have your "problem".

Gavin

GavinG wrote:The present pot would seem to be a tad too dark and massive.

The jin is wild - a must-keep feature. The top of the new pot clashes with it, so not a good match.

Maybe a grey unglazed pot with a smaller base or a bit less visual mass?

Let the tree do the talking.

Just a thought. I'd love to have your "problem".

Gavin

Hi Gavin,

Good to see you on line.

Welcome to and I hope you enjoy living in canberra.

Grant

Pup wrote:

Grant Bowie wrote:There aren't any of these pots in Canberra so I will have a look next time I am down in Melbourne. Its always difficult till you see, feel the pot and really get a handle on it.

Thanks for the feed back.

Grant

Lorraine Simpson of the Morington Penisula bonsai Club mate she will custom make it if you give her the measurements. I will pm her email

Thanks Pup,

A similar pot but without too much height may be the way to go.

Grant

Its always good to go local of course but just for interest here's some i found on erinbonsai.com ...

Trying to find the progression of this remarkable tree, I know I saw it somewhere. Can anyone point me in the right direction? It was fascinating to see the many changes over the years

Anja wrote:Trying to find the progression of this remarkable tree, I know I saw it somewhere. Can anyone point me in the right direction? It was fascinating to see the many changes over the years

Here it is,

viewtopic.php?f=104&t=831&hilit=Golden+cedar

Grant

nealweb wrote:Its always good to go local of course but just for interest here's some i found on erinbonsai.com ...

Yes thats the sort of thing.

Thanks to Pup I have the contact details for the local artist and will do some tracking down soon.

I will repot it this year as it has quite a few years in the same pot.

Grant

Grant, I make pots similar to those posted and in a range of sizes. You might see something you like at the convention.
Penny.